NBA gets defensive with Congress

21 07 2009

The Associated Press reported on Monday that the NBA has defended its minimum age requirement to Congress through official correspondence. My last post was about U.S. Rep. Steve Cohen (D-Tenn.), and he was the lucky recipient of a letter from NBA President Joel Litvin. In the letter, Litvin said that the age policy protects the NBA’s business interests by “increasing the chances that incoming players will have the requisite ability, experience, maturity and life skills” to compete at the pro level.

Litvin added that the policy helps teams make better personnel decisions, gives players an extra year to mature and develop, and does not force players to attend college against their wishes. Litvin pointed out that many employers require job candidates to have post-high school experience and turned the tables on Cohen by reminding him that there are age requirements for the House, Senate, and White House.

In a written response to Litvin, Cohen stuck to his guns and said the players should have the “economic freedom” to join the NBA from high school. Cohen is on the House Judiciary Committee and has requested a meeting with Litvin and NBA Commissioner David Stern. If the age requirement remains part of the league’s current collective bargaining policy, Cohen has said he’ll consider both holding hearings and proposing legislation.

// // <![CDATA[
var yahooBuzzArticleId = 'usatoday:'+storyURL+'?csp=34';
var yahooBuzzBadgeType = 'text';

var sclListTop = "";
sclListTop +='

';
sclListTop +='

    ';
    sclListTop +='

      ';
      sclListTop +='

      ';
      sclListTop +='

      ';
      sclListTop +='

    • this element will be replaced ';

      sclListTop +='

    •  Digg
    • ';
      //sclListTop +='

    •  del.icio.us
    • ';
      sclListTop +='

    •  Newsvine
    • ';
      sclListTop +='

    •  Reddit
    • ';
      sclListTop +='

    •  Facebook
    • ';
      sclListTop +='

    • What\'s this?
    • ';
      sclListTop +='';
      sclListTop +='';
      sclListTop +='

      ';
      sclListTop +='';
      document.write(sclListTop);
      // -->]]>

      WASHINGTON (AP) — The NBA defended its minimum age requirement to Congress, but a critical lawmaker was unmoved and is asking to meet with top league officials to discuss it, according to letters obtained Monday by the Associated Press.

      The rule, which is part of the league’s collective bargaining agreement with the players union, requires that players be at least 19 years old and a year out of high school before entering the league. Last month, Democratic Rep. Steve Cohen urged the league and union to scrap the requirement in the next collective bargaining agreement, calling it unfair.

      NBA President Joel Litvin told Cohen in a recent letter the purpose of the requirement is to promote the league’s business interests by “increasing the chances that incoming players will have the requisite ability, experience, maturity and life skills” to perform at a high level. The policy also helps teams make informed hiring decisions, he wrote.

      In addition, he said, players get an extra year to mature and develop, making it more likely they can handle the challenges of being an NBA player.

      Litvin said the policy is motivated by “business considerations,” not a desire to force players to attend college against their wishes.

      FIND MORE STORIES IN: Steve Cohen

      He wrote that many employers require job candidates to have post-high school experience, and that the U.S. Constitution sets minimum ages for House of Representatives members, senators and the president. Given that, “we do not understand your objection” to the rule, Litvin wrote.

      In a letter sent to Litvin on Monday, Cohen maintained that players should have the “economic freedom” to make their own decisions. He said he understood that the policy may help the league in its scouting and hiring decisions.

      “However, my concern is that the players who must abide by this rule are harmed by the league’s pursuit of these business interests,” the congressman wrote, adding that the “age discrimination” prevents players from supporting their families.

      The policy increases the chance that such players will be injured before getting the chance to play in the NBA, he added.

      “I am concerned that the careers of young men who possess all the skills necessary to succeed in the NBA,” Cohen wrote, “may be sacrificed in favor of the bottom lines of the teams on which they hope to play.”

      Cohen, a member of the House Judiciary Committee, asked for a meeting with Litvin and Commissioner David Stern. Cohen has said that that he’d consider both hearings and legislation if the requirement remains.

      Neither the NBA nor the union immediately responded to requests for comment Monday.

      Copyright 2009 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

      // <![CDATA[
      var OutbrainPermaLink=storyURL;
      var OB_Template = "usatoday";
      var OB_demoMode = false;
      var OBITm = "1241731960421";
      var OB_langJS ='http://widgets.outbrain.com/lang_en.js';
      if ( typeof(OB_Script)!='undefined' )
      OutbrainStart();
      else {
      var OB_Script = true;
      var str = '';
      document.write(str);
      }

      // ]]>

      // <![CDATA[
      var yahooBuzzArticleId = 'usatoday:'+storyURL+'?csp=34';
      var yahooBuzzBadgeType = 'text';

      var sclListBottom = "";
      sclListBottom +='

      ';
      sclListBottom +='

      ';
      sclListBottom +='

      Share this story:

      ';
      sclListBottom +='

      ';
      sclListBottom +='';
      sclListBottom +='

      ';
      sclListBottom +='

      ';
      sclListBottom +='

        ';
        sclListBottom +='

          ';

          sclListBottom +=' this element will be replaced ';

          sclListBottom +='';
          sclListBottom +=' ';
          sclListBottom +='Digg';
          sclListBottom +='
          ';

          sclListBottom +='';
          sclListBottom +=' ';
          sclListBottom +='Newsvine';
          sclListBottom +='
          ';
          sclListBottom +='';
          sclListBottom +=' ';
          sclListBottom +='Reddit';
          sclListBottom +='
          ';
          sclListBottom +='';
          sclListBottom +=' ';
          sclListBottom +='Facebook';
          sclListBottom +='
          ';
          sclListBottom +='';
          sclListBottom +='What\'s this?';
          sclListBottom +='
          ';
          sclListBottom +='';
          sclListBottom +='';
          sclListBottom +='';
          sclListBottom +='

          ';
          sclListBottom +='';
          document.write(sclListBottom);
          // -->]]>

          Posted // 22h 5m ago E-mail | Save | Print | // <![CDATA[
          var tempshowReprintSSI = "";
          if(window.showReprintSSI)
          {
          tempshowReprintSSI = showReprintSSI;
          }
          if ((navigator.os.indexOf("Mac")==1) && (navigator.type==2))
          { // macIE
          if((document.forms.hiddenValForm.hiddenMacPrintValue.value == "0") || (document.forms.hiddenValForm.hiddenMacPrintValue.value=="2"))
          {
          if(document.forms.hiddenValForm.hiddenMacPrintValue.value == "2"){
          document.forms.hiddenValForm.hiddenMacPrintValue.value = "0";
          }
          else{
          document.forms.hiddenValForm.hiddenMacPrintValue.value = "1";
          }
          if(tempshowReprintSSI == 'showReprintSSI'){
          writeReprintLink();
          }
          writeSubscribeToLink();
          }
          else
          {
          document.forms.hiddenValForm.hiddenMacPrintValue.value = "2";
          }
          }
          else
          {// non macIE - write top and bottom

          if(tempshowReprintSSI == 'showReprintSSI'){
          writeReprintLink();
          }
          writeSubscribeToLink();
          }

          function writeReprintLink(){
          document.write('Reprints & Permissions | ');
          }
          function writeSubscribeToLink(){
          var url = document.location.toString();
          var urlArray = url.split("/")
          var nurl = "";
          for (i = 3; i < urlArray.length - 1; i++)
          {
          if(i<urlArray.length-2){
          nurl += urlArray[i] + "|";
          }
          else
          {
          nurl += urlArray[i];
          }
          }
          document.write('Subscribe to stories like this‘);
          }
          // ]]>Subscribe to stories like this

          To report corrections and clarifications, contact Reader Editor Brent Jones. For publication consideration in the newspaper, send comments to letters@usatoday.com. Include name, phone number, city and state for verification. To view our corrections, go to corrections.usatoday.com.
          Guidelines: You share in the USA TODAY community, so please keep your comments smart and civil. Don’t attack other readers personally, and keep your language decent. Use the “Report Abuse” button to make a difference. Read more.

          Add your comment: You are logged in as novak135

          <!–

          Comments: (23)

          Showing:   Newest first Oldest first Most recommended New: Most recommended!
          User Image
          STDREAM (0 friends, send message) wrote: 8h 58m ago
          If an 18 year old can serve this country in the military, they should be able to play any professional -ball that is offered in this country. At the end of the day it will still be what it always is-discrimination by the NBA and their farm-league,the NCAA. I guess foreign ballplayers mature faster than the kids here in the U.S., since they can play at under 18 in a lot of these . Expect to see more 17 and 18 year-old american basketball players leaving the country for the opportunities thaty are available outside the USA.
          User Image
          reecedawg (9 friends, send message) wrote: 21h 19m ago
          DUMBEST RULE EVER……….we have 16 yr old pro tennis players and golfers why not basketball, kids are smart though, keep em out now and they get paid to go overseas and play right out of highschool.
          User Image
          odie (0 friends, send message) wrote: 17h 30m ago
          Playing in professional sports ought to be like having a drivers license! It should be a priviledge, not a god given right. Maybe sports can eliminate some of the problem childs before they prove they didn’t deserve the chance in the first place.
          User Image
          hurls (7 friends, send message) wrote: 19h 22m ago
          Wait until the NBA, and other professional sports come into the same arena as corporate America. The majority of corporate America is now, more and more making a bachelors degree a “minimum” requirement for even low level jobs. This has been a result of being sued because someone got the job over another gender or race. Can you imagine if the NBA made a college degree (not attending, but legitimate degree) before they let anyone play in the NBA. Good bye Kobe, Lebron, etc., etc.

          Personally, I think the existing rule is perfect. These young men already have a hard time with the sudden wealth, attention and the lack of maturity to handle it.

          User Image
          louisianatiger19 (0 friends, send message) wrote: 1h 40m ago
          Is anyone else sick and tired of Congress meddling in sports? Don’t they have enough problems in Washington to take care of? If they want to get into sports, they should declare the Nationals a federal disaster area.
          User Image
          sullysul (14 friends, send message) wrote: 12h 55m ago
          Why don’t they do this in Golf? Tennis? Figure-skating? Baseball? It’s all a lie. It’s not about age. It’s about dollars and yes it makes cents.
          User Image
          vincents60 (0 friends, send message) wrote: 20h 18m ago
          Amazing, we elect these idiots to run our country. I suggest Cohen gets back to doing the work the people elected him to do. We have too many congressmen with their nose in something that in no way resembles the job they were elected to. I suggest either he drops this and get back to doing his job or resign and let someone who cares about this country take his place
          User Image
          rford1001 (0 friends, send message) wrote: 21h 8m ago
          I thought there was rules that didn’t allow somebody to judge you on age and race
          User Image
          rford1001 (0 friends, send message) wrote: 21h 9m ago
          The problem is they already let the young players in and they made themselves into all stars so how can you stop it now. Sounds to me that college basketball had a hand in trying to keep them there.
          User Image
          ROSSJW1 (0 friends, send message) wrote: 1h ago
          I want congress to step in. This rule is racist and serves no real purpose other than making kids go to college so the NCAA can PIMP them!
          More comments on this story: 1 2 3 Next



Actions

Information

One response

7 08 2009
Looking back on this project « Hoop Teens

[...] NBA gets defensive with Congress [...]

Leave a comment